Skip to main content

Mod 14 Curriculum Selection Activity 2

Mod 14 Curriculum Selection Activity 2

Mod 14 Curriculum Selection Activity 2
by omayda Valdez -
Number of replies: 0

Title: Civics Today: Citizenship, Economics, & You (Student Edition)
Publisher: Glencoe/McGraw-Hill
Publication date/edition: 2008, 4th ed., 866 pp. (ISBN 0078746329) (Google Books)
Typical grade band: 7–10 (catalogs list Grades 8–12) (UW-Madison Libraries)
Scope/TOC evidence: Units span foundations of citizenship, national/state/local government, parties/interest groups, law, economy/free enterprise, and U.S. & the world (TOC/feature lists). (UW-Madison Libraries)

Ratings 

1) Standards support – 4/5
Publisher materials emphasize alignment to civics/econ standards and “big ideas” per chapter. Strong for classic civics strands; alignment predates C3 (2013) and current Florida updates. (Google Books)

2) Cultural relevance & multicultural framing – 3/5
Broad U.S. civics focus with some world content; however, 2008 examples risk dated representation and limited contemporary inclusion (e.g., recent movements, immigration perspectives, diverse civic actors). Needs supplemental voices. (UW-Madison Libraries)

3) Content support (accuracy/scope) – 4/5
Comprehensive civics/econ overview across eight units; strong structure for a year course. Currency is the main caveat (policies/cases changed since 2008). (UW-Madison Libraries)

4) Readability & grade applicability – 3/5
Readable for MS/HS, but dense (866 pp.) and written before current readability-aware design trends (chunking, diverse text sets). Some learners will need leveled alternatives. (Google Books)

5) Content objectives clarity – 4/5
Chapters built around “big ideas” and explicit unit aims, which map cleanly to targets/essential questions. (caggiasocialstudies.com)

6) Graphic support (graphs/charts) – 4/5
Glencoe civics texts typically include charts/diagrams; teacher studies reference feature-rich layouts that support comprehension, though specific equity-minded graphics vary by chapter. (McGraw Hill)

7) Visual support (photos/illustrations) – 4/5
Student-friendly design noted by publisher; visuals aid access, but representation may reflect 2000s conventions rather than today’s multicultural best practices. (Google Books)

8) Vocabulary (Tier 1/2/3) & workload to adapt – 3/5
Academic vocabulary is robust; expect to add multilingual glossaries, morphology frames, and pictorial supports for earlier ELL stages. (UW-Madison Libraries)

9) Bias – 3/5
Mainstream civics framing; neutral tone overall, but limited space for counter-narratives, community perspectives, and global comparative civics unless teacher supplements. (UW-Madison Libraries)

10) Differentiation & scaffolding for ELLs – 2/5
As a 2008 print-first text, built-in ELL scaffolds are modest compared to modern platforms (audio, translation, leveled reads). McGraw-Hill’s newer Florida Civics digital suite adds those features—but that’s a different product. (McGraw Hill)

Overall rating: 3.4/5 (Adopt with conditions / pilot + supplement).

Adoption Decision

Conditional adoption for a civics course if your district already owns copies—only with a robust support plan for ELLs and cultural relevance. If purchasing new, prioritize a more current, accessibility-rich option (e.g., 2024 Florida editions or We the People middle/high school updates with digital supports). (Amazon)

Differentiation, Scaffolding, Tiering (to fill gaps)

For ELL progress continuum:

  • Preproduction/Early Production: pictorial word walls, bilingual/visual glossaries, sentence stems; teacher-created slide decks that preteach Tier 2/3 terms (branches, due process, interest group).

  • Speech Emergence: cloze notes from chapter sections; Frayer models; caption-this with textbook visuals; partner retell using frames.

  • Intermediate Fluency: jigsaw readings with leveled summaries; graphic organizers for case studies; text-dependent Qs with optional audio.

  • Advanced Fluency: DBQs with primary sources; compare/contrast U.S. and home-country civic structures; Socratic seminars.

Tech & access add-ons:

  • Read-aloud/audio + translation (district ebook or LMS plug-ins); leveled news articles matched to each chapter concept.

  • Primary-source sets & simulations (e.g., mock hearings from We the People; add current topics for representation and relevance). (UNM Digital Repository)

Outline: School Guidelines for Selecting a Textbook for Inclusive Classrooms

  1. Alignment & Coherence: State standards + C3 inquiry practices; transparent learning progressions and assessments. (National Council for the Social Studies)

  2. Cultural & Linguistic Relevance: Contemporary, representative examples; multiple perspectives; anti-bias review.

  3. Universal Design & ELL Supports: Audio, translation, leveled readings, visuals, explicit language aims, sentence frames, formative checks.

  4. Assessment Accessibility: Varied modalities (writing/speaking/performance); bias-checked items.

  5. Teacher Tooling: Editable tasks, pacing, intervention & extension pathways.

Recognized selection process (for a multicultural student body):

  • Screen publishers for the above criteria using the Selection Criteria sheet; short-list only texts meeting baseline ELL & UDL supports.

  • Committee review (general ed, ELL/ESOL, SPED, students/families) with an anti-bias checklist and sample lesson try-outs.

  • Pilot in diverse classrooms; collect ELL progress/engagement data; finalize with public summary and gap-mitigation plan.

Brief Critique of the Current Non-Textbook (trade books/web/software) Process & Fixes

Typical gaps: teacher-by-teacher choices, inconsistent bias checks, uneven ELL supports.
Improvements:

  • Require a mini-review (cultural relevance + ELL access) before classroom use.

  • Maintain a curated list of approved non-text materials tagged by reading level, language supports, and cultural lenses.

  • Schedule quarterly refresh to add current voices (local communities, contemporary civics issues).